San Francisco to form committee and develop new student device policy |
San Francisco USD plans to retain its current cellphone policy, which requires student devices to be turned off and out of sight during instructional time and between classes, allowing the district to comply with California’s July 1 deadline for regulating student device use. At the same time, the school board is expected to launch a lengthy review process, including an ad hoc committee of board members, educators, students, and parents, to develop a new policy for consideration in 2027. The effort comes amid growing debate over whether schools should adopt full bell-to-bell cellphone bans, with supporters citing reduced distractions, improved student engagement, and fewer bullying incidents, while opponents raise concerns about emergency communication, enforcement challenges, and mixed research findings on academic and well-being outcomes. Survey results show strong support for tighter restrictions within the district, although staff report that the current policy is not consistently enforced.